Wild Horse Nine finds humor in despair on Easter Island

BY TYLER HENSON

Wild Horse Nine (117 mins)

Easter Island is sure an odd place to find two CIA agents, particularly ones embroiled in a Chilean coup and attempting to grasp what it means to die. That’s where Chris (John Malkovich) and Lee (Sam Rockwell) are stuck. Chris is in a bad way, terminally ill, his memory fading, quietly grappling with the morality of his life and deeds. Lee is along for the ride, a friend and confidant, possibly tasked with ushering Chris off onto his final destination.

Wild Horse Nine, the fifth film from writer/director Martin McDonagh, an Irish playwright turned filmmaker, has a lot in common with his first, In Bruges (2008). That film stared Colin Farrell and Brendan Gleeson as hitmen on vacation, you guessed it, in Bruges, where they struggle with moral questions and Catholic guilt. The older Gleeson attempts to atone for his own sins and impart some desperate wisdom on the younger Farrell before it’s too late. That film was cynical, vulgar, violent, funny, and seriously concerned with the nature of good and evil. Wild Horse Nine is a more mature version of the same.

The two leads of this film are older and less impulsive than the Gleeson and Farrell characters were in In Bruges. They’re quieter and more reflective, and so is the film they inhabit. McDonagh’s work is known for flipping unpredictably in tone. In all of his films, which includes Seven Psychopaths (2012) and the Oscar-winning Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri (2017), he has cultivated a skill at using graphic violence to abruptly steer scenes of obscenely comic banter into shocking and unexpected directions. His stories can never be predicted and his characters are capable of loathsome behavior. However much McDonagh’s writing evokes spiritual longing and pain, he never wants the people in his films to be easy to like.

His more rambunctious habits have been toned down for Wild Horse. There is very little onscreen violence. There are not many scenes of tense confrontation that lead to chaotic outcomes. There are some, but not many. The bulk of the runtime is devoted to these two guys, Chris and Lee, hanging out, taking in the sights, and talking. Sometimes they talk about things of consequence, sometimes not. There is not always a clear plot objective in mind. McDonagh lets the tension, the pain and bitterness, the regret, swirl under the surface while his characters attempt, without much success, to distract themselves from their problems.

It’s a relationship built with care in McDonagh’s screenplay, and fleshed out beautifully in Malkovich and Rockwell’s performances. The writing is richly nuanced. Chris and Lee’s past, the years spent in close proximity as fixers and assassins, is felt even in casual moments, as is a love and respect neither really has to acknowledge. Trust is another matter. Work may be pitting them against one another. Back at the office, their boss, MJ (Steve Buscemi), is getting worried about Chris’ forgetful behavior. There’s talk that he may be working on his memoirs. Considering the secrets to which Chris has been privy, MJ sure has reason to pressure Lee on his loyalties.

Lee is uncertain where he stands, and the suspense of the film is hinged on his decision. Will he do his job, or will he stand by Chris? He can see Chris is becoming a liability, blabbing openly to whomever will listen about political machinations and murders. Rockwell’s continuing exasperation is among the film’s comic high points. One of the funniest scenes features Lee delicately attempting to bring up the subject of Chris’ impending death, asking if Easter Island was everything he hoped it would be. Chris doesn’t understand the question. Easter Island? Didn’t he say he wanted to die in Venice? Who said anything about Easter Island? It’s flawlessly played.

There are several priceless conversations like this, including an extended chat on the possibility of spiritual salvation for dinosaurs, but underpinning the humor is a terrible sense of finality and remorse. Chris is at a place where he’s beginning to believe that his job, his many professional successes and failures, his very life, may have been wasted on bad decisions and wrong assumptions. His wistful attitude hides a storm of anger and disgust, though he spends no time feeling sorry for himself. McDonagh’s characters tend to accept their fates with hard honesty. Chris knows it’s too late to save his soul, but at the very least he hopes to find some meaning in death he couldn’t in life.

Lee, in spite of himself, is in the process of asking many of the same existential questions. As the two of them pretend, as much as they can, that their Easter Island trip is nothing more than a vacation, melancholy sets in and grief begins to pervade every joke. There are many silences where they are left struggling to think of what they actually want to say to one another. It’s a tragic film in its discreet way, far sadder than anything McDonagh has made previously. Malkovich is being talked about as one of the year’s strongest Oscar contenders, and his work here ranks among the best of his career.

The violence does begin to arrive in the final stretch, as well as some slightly preposterous revelations that let us know McDonagh isn’t going to let serious intentions stop him from being playful and provocative. As always, he has surprises waiting up his sleeve. One that deserves mention is Parker Posey’s appearance as Lee’s wife. At first, it appears as though her character is going to be nothing more than the cheating, belligerent wife who bickers mercilessly with her husband. But McDonagh’s writing attempts something trickier by suggesting that, in some damaged way, she and Lee actually do love each other.

It should be mentioned as well that the location work and cinematography are outstanding. Much as he did with In Bruges, McDonagh utilizes his picturesque setting exceptionally well, and it offers perfect counterpoint to the story. One doesn’t expect a dark, downbeat, and harsh film to be so visually bright, expansive, and beautiful. What better way to present such a morose entertainment? The edgy charms of the characters and the quotable strength of the dialogue round out the package. This is a Martin McDonagh film, through and through.

About Tyler Henson

Tyler Henson is a writer and filmmaker originally from the Oregon coast. He's written and directed short films, acted and crewed on independent productions in the Portland area, and even worked concession and projection at movie theaters. His film reviews have been featured in the DVC Inquirer. He lives with his spouse, son, and physical media collection in Pleasant Hill.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Check Also

Miley’s Bass Persuades continues her evolution as a solo artist

BY XAVIER JOHNSON For millennials and Zoomers, Miley Cyrus has been a constant presence in …