BY XAVIER JOHNSON
Celebrating their 50th Anniversary, it’s been quite a while since the legendary Irish band U2 released a full-length, all-original studio album: 2017’s Songs of Experience. A relatively understated release compared to its predecessors, Songs of Experience was well received, but there’s seemingly a conflicted underlying feeling around the band.
U2 remain one of the biggest bands in the world and their name still carries weight. But their biggest hits of the 21st century, like “Vertigo,” are now 22 years old, and their pace has slowed considerably since their prolific 20th-century output. Still, they’ve kept a more experimental edge than some of their contemporaries, whether it’s featuring on Kendrick Lamar’s DAMN. or turning their residency at the Sphere in Las Vegas into quite the spectacle. Even 2023’s Songs of Surrender, which revisited forty of their older songs, felt like a band exploring its catalog in an interesting way.

2026 has been an intriguing year for U2, with Days of Ash and Easter Lily, a pair of surprise EPs dropped during Lent. Released on Ash Wednesday and Good Friday, they were the band’s first full sets of newly written songs since Songs of Experience, and they felt urgent and motivated. Days of Ash looked outward, ready to match the current political moment. Whether it was addressing the invasion of Ukraine or, on “American Obituary,” the ICE killing of Renee Good in Minneapolis, U2 felt like they had an artistic calling to meet what feels like a confluence of global tipping points. Easter Lily turned inward with songs about loss and hope.
The EPs were a sign of what was to come: a band that sounded like it had something it needed to say. The challenge is sustaining that urgency across a studio album which brings different expectations than a pair of EPs. U2 mostly accomplish this with Carnaval De Luz, their 15th studio album, which is built on energy, optimism and joy.
Carnaval De Luz is a capital-R Rock album. “Go (Carnaval De Luz)” is a fantastic way to start the record. It’s an anthem which acts as a sonic mission statement. The song jaunts along with a palpable and bouncy rhythm that’s pure, concentrated momentum. It’s a brief track, but it’s the perfect jumping on point for one of the highpoints of the track list, “La Reina.”
This straightforward rock tune shines with The Edge’s crunchy guitar tone and prominent rhythm section from bassist Adam Clayton and drummer Larry Mullen Jr. It’s also a great moment for Bono, whose vocals feel as strong as they’ve been this century. The extended bridge offers a nice detour into a more spacey sound with some excellent harmonies and synths.
The bassline on the killer single “Silencio” is one of the best musical moments on the album. The way Bono’s soaring vocals and the instrumentation dance around that bassline shows a band operating at a high level.
This is also an optimistic record. This feels like an intentional choice and quite a political one. It’s clear from Days of Ash that U2 are keenly aware of the fractured state of much of the world, but while that record looked at the bad to cast a light upon it, Carnaval De Luz feels like a beacon for those prone to falling into darkness. While the world might be struggling, the album argues that the answer is love and community. “The Greatest Show On Earth” explores finding meaning and explorations of faith, sincerity, complex love and redemption. This message, in an age of struggle and transactional relationships, is a welcome one.
Above all, Carnaval De Luz is a joyous album. These songs just straight up feel good. U2 craft some uplifting, exciting tracks that aren’t sappy. Tracks like “Glorify” and “Midnight Sunshine” are smiles in a bottle. The Edge’s guitar work is fittingly delicate, and Bono’s vocals yet again carry a comforting timbre supporting some truly vibrant lyricism
Occasionally, though, the album dips into a safe, pillowy territory that just doesn’t work. “Street Of Dreams” sounds too commercial and familiar. The poppy guitar riffs, glossy production and forgettable chorus don’t land, but expect it to be in a Kohl’s ad soon. Compared to the moments of raw energy on “La Reina” and “Silencio,” this is contrived. “Can’t Stop Us Now” is another track that’s unremarkable. Its flat chorus and arrangement don’t stick, and where Bono usually offers something interesting in terms of tone or rhythm, here he mostly disappears. In the track list it stalls the momentum between “Midnight Sunshine” and “Torn,” two superior songs.
That leaves the album to close on a high. “Torn” features vocals from the late Dolly Parton in her final recording. According to interviews, Parton originally brought the band a traditional country song about a woman torn between two lovers, and U2 reworked it into a song about families divided by politics. “Torn” is especially gorgeous, with Bono and Dolly sharing a track with some of the finest lyrical moments on the record. The multilayered exploration of interpersonal conflict and a world divided is rich in lines that hold many meanings, such as “Nothing hurts a mother more than a family at war.”
Across Carnaval De Luz, this is a motivated band that isn’t showing their age. As listeners, we’re all too accustomed to classic rock bands falling into paint-by-numbers art, but U2 feel like a band that took their time before releasing music, waiting for a time when they really needed to play. Despite a couple of misfires, Carnaval De Luz carries the urgency of this year’s EPs across a full album, with some truly great songs. U2’s massive legacy alone will carry this record up the charts, but the quality matches the stature. U2’s newest album is not just good for a classic rock band; it’s good, period.
Martinez Tribune The website of the Martinez Tribune.
